Implicit Loyalty vs Explicit Loyalty

Repeat buyers are not always loyal. The difference between implicit and explicit loyalty, and why only one gives you an edge.

Rahi Jain, Subscription LTV Specialist

Repeat Buyers ≠ Loyal Customers

Most brands mistake repeat purchases for loyalty.

An average person makes 35,000 choices per day.

Due to this, most decisions are made without any second thought.

That leads to implicit loyalty for brands.

Implicit loyalty will show in numbers and in cohort analysis.

Their repeat purchases could be driven by convenience, pricing, or lack of alternatives rather than genuine loyalty or satisfaction with the brand.

However, these customers are susceptible to pricing, location, and competition.

They will not refer friends, go out of their way, post on social media, etc.

In short, they will not give you a COMPETITIVE ADVANTAGE.

Eventually, you want them to move to explicit loyalty.

True loyalty often involves a deeper emotional connection with the brand.

They not only purchase repeatedly but also advocate for the company, provide positive feedback, and show resistance to switching to competitors.

To build emotional loyalty, start by –

  • Building communities around a topic
  • Do mission or cause-based marketing
  • Creating a unique brand voice and experience

Don’t mistake implicit loyalty for the loyalty you need to grow profitably.

It’s just people have not given it a second thought.

Liked this? Get the next issue in your inbox.

One email a week on subscription retention: the numbers, the strategy, and what to fix first.

About the author

Rahi Jain is a subscription LTV specialist who helps DTC brands maximize their LTV from subscriptions.

The Subscription Retention Newsletter

The numbers, the strategy, and what to fix first. One email a week.

Free subscription audit

Not sure where to start? Get your Subscription LTV Scorecard™

The same audit we run on every paying client, free.

Just your email and store URL.

RELATED ARTICLES

2 BFCM Mistakes Every Subscription Brand Makes

5 Shopify Retention Reports You Can Pull for Free

5 Shopify Retention Reports You Can Pull for Free

Scale a CPG Brand Without Paid Ads: The 9-Step System

Scale a CPG Brand Without Paid Ads: The 9-Step System

5 Repeat Purchase Mistakes Killing Your Retention

5 Repeat Purchase Mistakes Killing Your Retention

7 Klaviyo Subscription Automations to Cut Churn

7 Klaviyo Subscription Automations to Cut Churn