RetainUPBook a call

ZitSticka Skincare Subscription Case Study: The Subscription in Every Flow, 43% More Flow Conversions

ZitSticka sells acne care on monthly subscription, and retention was low. We put the subscription pitch and a cancel winback in every core flow. Flow conversions rose 43% in the first month.

Rahi Jain
, Subscription LTV Specialist
· Updated · 3 min read
Woman pointing at her cheek, surrounded by ZitSticka acne patch boxes

Key takeaways

  • ZitSticka's automation conversions rose 43% in the first month after we put the subscription in every core flow.
  • A subscriber who cancelled got a survey and 25% off the next order.
  • We have no subscription retention number on file for ZitSticka. Every result here is a first-month email number.

The brand and the problem

ZitSticka sells pimple patches, skincare and supplements on monthly subscription, and retention was low. ZitSticka sells to teens and young adults who take care of their skin early and want science-backed products.

ZitSticka found us through Heyday, a digital brand platform, at the end of May 2024, the same month as Boka and FreshCap. The brand sold monthly subscription programs for its products.

What we found

ZitSticka had a big list and no regular reason for it to hear about the subscription. It had 339K people on its email list and no regular campaigns going to them.

What we built

We built 5 core flows with the subscription first, a cancel winback, and a campaign calendar that kept selling the subscription.

The subscription offer

Every automation showed the subscription benefits and the discounts that came with them. One in four campaigns each month had a section for the subscription.

Lifecycle flows

In 2 months we built 5 core automations: welcome, browse abandonment, cart abandonment, incomplete checkout and canceled subscription. The goal was more repeat buyers.

Cancel and winback

A subscriber who cancelled got a survey and 25% off the next order.

Campaigns, pop-ups and SMS

We planned a monthly campaign calendar around the best-selling products. The tone was conversational and young, to match the audience. Welcome pop-ups named the visitor's pain point and what ZitSticka offered for it: a solution and a discount. As the list grew, SMS carried the time-sensitive offers.

Results

ZitSticka's automation conversions rose 43% in the first month after we put the subscription in every flow. We have no subscription retention or repeat purchase number on file for ZitSticka, so every number below is a first-month email number.

ZitSticka email results: $38.17K to $39.65K in 30 days, campaign AOV up 8.24%
  • Automation conversions: up 43%.
  • Automation revenue: $39.65K, 3.88% higher than before.
  • Automation click rate: doubled.
  • Campaign AOV: $64.45 to $69.76, 8.24% higher.
  • Campaign click rate: up 1.82%.
  • Deliverability: up 57.08%, with 999,838 emails delivered.

What you can copy

Put the subscription in every flow you already run, and give a cancel a reason to come back.

  • Show the subscription benefits and the discount in your welcome, browse, cart and checkout flows.
  • Ask a cancelled subscriber why, and pair the survey with an offer on the next order. ZitSticka used 25% off.
  • Give the subscription a section in some of your regular campaigns. ZitSticka used one in four.
  • Test subject lines on your flows so deliverability holds.

FAQs

What did RetainUP build for ZitSticka's subscription?

5 core automations in 2 months: welcome, browse abandonment, cart abandonment, incomplete checkout and canceled subscription. Each one showed the subscription benefits, and one in four campaigns each month had a subscription section.

What happens when a ZitSticka subscriber cancels?

They get a survey and 25% off the next order.

What results did ZitSticka get in the first month?

Automation conversions rose 43%, and automation revenue reached $39.65K, 3.88% above the past level. The click rate doubled and campaign AOV rose 8.24%. We have no subscription retention number on file for ZitSticka.

Which other subscription brands came through Heyday?

Boka, whose month 3 retention went from 41% to 63%, and FreshCap, whose returning customer rate went from 69% to 79%.

Find where your own subscription program leaks

The free Subscription LTV Scorecard finds the leaks in your subscription program. It scores your program on 48 checkpoints across 8 dimensions, from public data, and lands in your inbox within 24 hours.

Rahi Jain
About the author

Rahi Jain

Rahi Jain is a subscription LTV specialist who helps $1M to $10M DTC brands reduce subscription churn and maximize LTV on Recharge, Skio, Stay AI and Loop.

More about Rahi

More subscription case studies

Real results from subscription brands, with the numbers before and after. All of them side by side on the Results page.

Cover for the Naali supplement subscription case study by RetainUP, with the Naali and Stay AI logos
Case Studies

Supplement Subscription Case Study: Naali's Order 2 Retention From 64% to 78% on Stay AI

How Naali, a French supplement brand on Stay AI, lifted monthly order 2 retention from 64% to 78% with 13 flows and a cancel flow built by reason.

Nov 13, 2026
Cover for the SunMed CBD subscription case study by RetainUP, with the SunMed and Skio logos
Case Studies

CBD Subscription Case Study: SunMed's Month 3 Retention From 61% to 73% on Skio

How SunMed, a CBD brand on Skio, lifted month 3 retention from 61% to 73% with eight lifecycle flows and a rebuilt cancel flow, with no new discount.

Nov 13, 2026
Man with a Fitlab meal plan bag and meal boxes on a blue background
Case Studies

Fitlab Meal Plan Subscription Case Study: 26% More Subscriptions in a Month

Fitlab's meal plan subscriptions grew 26% in May 2024 against April. It had about 8K lapsed subscribers, and we built the flows from the meal plan quiz to the paused plan.

Jan 2, 2025
FreshCap mushroom extract jars on a driftwood branch
Case Studies

FreshCap Mushroom Subscription Case Study: Returning Customer Rate From 69% to 79%

FreshCap's returning customer rate went from 69% to 79%. We timed reorders to its hero product and rebuilt subscription onboarding, renewal reminders and churn saves.

Sep 5, 2024
Boka nano-hydroxyapatite toothpaste tubes and an electric toothbrush
Case Studies

Boka Oral Care Subscription Case Study: Month 3 Retention From 41% to 63%

Boka's month 3 retention went from 41% to 63%. We rebuilt the three moments that decide it on Recharge: the renewal reminder, the failed card and the cancel.

Sep 5, 2024
Woman arranging BloomsyBox flowers in her kitchen
Case Studies

Flower Subscription Case Study: BloomsyBox Winback Flows Took Automation Revenue From $157,527 to $193,518

BloomsyBox had few active flower subscriptions and many lapsed ones. We wired Recharge into Klaviyo and built winback flows for each kind of lapsed subscriber. Automation revenue rose from $157,527 to $193,518.

Sep 4, 2024
Scorecard report mockup
Free subscription audit

Not sure where to start? Get your Subscription LTV Scorecard™

The same audit we run on every paying client, free.

  • A personalized 20-page report
  • 8 dimensions, 48 checkpoints
  • Benchmarked against Grüns, IM8 and Mars Men
  • Delivered in 24 hours

Just your email and store URL.